Post

The Immersion Fallacy

The Immersion Fallacy

First of all, I want to clearly express that I do think immersion is important in games. Just like when watching movies or reading books, you don’t want your suspension of disbelief to be broken, because that just pulls you out of it. You want to stay engrossed by what’s happening.

What I really want from a video game (as well as from a good movie or book) though, does go beyond just mere immersion. I want to get so absorbed that I temporarily forget my surroundings and lose track of time. I want to be “in the zone”. And I think that’s a step further than just feeling immersed, and that immersiveness alone isn’t quite enough to achieve that.

Quite to the contrary: adding more immersiveness just for the sake of it, might even introduce counter-productive distractions that make it more difficult to get into the zone - or even yank you straight out of it. Contrary to common belief, more immersion might not automatically be “more better”.

Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi’s Flow

Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi was a Hungarian-American psychologist, and the father of the psychological concept of flow. “Flow” describes exactly that state of being “in the zone”, I mentioned above:

Flow in positive psychology, also known colloquially as being “in the zone” or focused, is the mental state in which a person performing some activity is fully immersed in a feeling of energized focus, full involvement, and enjoyment in the process of the activity. In essence, flow is characterized by the complete absorption in what one does, and a resulting transformation in one’s sense of time.

Source: Wikipedia

Mihaly lists nine component states of achieving flow:

  • challenge-skill balance
  • merging of action and awareness
  • clarity of goals
  • immediate and unambiguous feedback
  • concentration on the task at hand
  • paradox of control (feeling in control of your actions, even when the outcome is uncertain or the challenge is difficult)
  • transformation of time (losing track of fast - or slow - time passes)
  • loss of self-consciousness
  • autotelic experience (doing the activity for its own sake, not for external rewards)

To achieve a flow state, a balance must be struck between the challenge of the task and the skill of the performer. If the task is too easy or too difficult, flow cannot occur as both skill level and challenge level must be matched and high.

Just from that short description, you should already be able to see, that video games are uniquely well suited for achieving flow. There’s a huge overlap between things that make for a good game, and things that help with achieving flow. Thus, when a video game really captures your attention, what’s happening is most likely, that you are entering such a state of flow.

And that’s exactly when playing a game becomes most engrossing and enjoyable. But absolutely do keep in mind, that this only works, if there is a non-trivial challenge to overcome. Games are very good at providing challenges that aren’t too hard, while still giving you that feeling of mastery, when you do overcome them. I also want to point out “clarity of goals” and “immediate and unambiguous feedback” as two further important elements, that games are very good at providing. (Or at least they should be. Failing to do that makes them worse games.)

Friction

Challenge is friction though. While you do want to remove unnecessary friction from a game through quality of life improvements - you can’t remove all friction because some is necessary in order to provide a challenge. If you were to actually remove all friction, you’d end up with something like Progress Quest - a “game” that basically plays itself. After character creation (which doesn’t matter), you have no further input. There’s zero interactivity, and it’s debatable if this self-running thing you can only watch even qualifies as a “game”. Despite that and despite being created as a joke/parody - it still did find a playerbase that’s seriously into it. But that’s how you achieve zero friction - by turning it into something that’s arguably not even a game.

What you want, is good friction. The kind that helps with flow. The kind that provides a balanced challenge, provides both clear goals and unambiguous feedback. Any friction that hinders flow, frustrates or bores or confuses the player, is of the bad kind. But you don’t necessarily always want to get rid of that by removing it. Sometimes it might be preferable to add more clarity, better defined goals and better feedback - and convert it into good friction instead. If you just remove it, you might be removing gameplay you actually want in the game.

There’s no universal, complete answer to what is good and bad friction. It greatly depends on the type of game, where it derives its challenge from, and also what kinds of challenges the target audience likes. But despite that gray area in the middle, other things might be more unequivocally bad or good. Like for example input lag is unequivocally bad in any game that relies on any kind of timing. Except for some fringe exceptions like those mecha games and their huge dedicated controllers, friction in the controls might not be a good thing for most games.

Looking through the lens of flow, it becomes pretty obvious why: you want the controls to become just second nature and muscle memory, and having to consciously think about what button to press breaks immersion and pulls you out of flow.

When seen from this angle, game design becomes all about choosing which friction to put into the game, and which friction to remove from the game. Deciding where the challenge should stem from - basically “friction design” - defines the game. It also tells you where you need that clarity of goals and unambiguous feedback, in order to create the good kind of friction.

How To Create Good Friction

Games are always an abstraction. You are not actually getting stabbed to death, you aren’t really shooting people in their heads. It’s a simulated experience in which you are operating on a simplified model of reality. Only the gameplay-relevant pieces are actually modelled - the rest is just ignored or skipped.

Just like most books and movies never mention anyone going to the bathroom, your game might not need a bathroom mechanic. The player (or reader/viewer) is willing to suspend disbelief and just assume that stuff happens off-screen during a cut or time-jump. Unless you are My Summer Car and want a pee-meter just for the laughs, you’re probably better off abstracting that sort of thing away. And the same is probably true for a lot of other details as well.

You probably don’t need physicalized cargo loading, tram rides and hygiene like Star Citizen does. Sure, it does increase immersiveness - but it also adds the bad kind of friction, that might just break flow, because of induced boredom or tedium. EvE Online is perfectly capable of achieving intense flow, despite abstracting away most ship flying details.

In fact, you have to abstract things away, in order to achieve the necessary prerequisites for flow. Fully realistic real-life stuff is just often way too messy, ambiguous and hard to understand - to be conducive to flow. And you can’t perfectly simulate everything down to the quantum level in the first place. You always operate on a simplified model and abstraction. And to be well-suited for flow, that abstraction needs to run on clear, understandable rules and provide good feedback - and to clearly communicate what the goal and the challenge is. That understanding is crucial to make the player feel in control, even in the face of uncertainty.

In real life, nothing is really clear and unambiguous. In the abstraction of the game, all of that is broken down into relatively simple rules and numbers. A learnable system that can be understood and mastered, but still comes with enough friction to provide a challenge that’s satisfying to overcome. A challenge at least difficult enough that the player is required to concentrate on what they’re doing. But not so difficult it becomes frustrating.

So in order to create good friction that helps with flow - you have to provide just the right level of abstraction and the rules (mechanics/systems) of your game have to ignore/simplify the unnecessary things, while making the desired friction clear, unambiguous and understandable - or in other words: learnable and thus overcomable through mastery.

The Fallacy

And that finally brings us to the fallacy I wanted to talk about.

Immersion is good and necessary for flow. And more immersiveness is often seen as kind of the holy grail. Star Trek’s Holodeck, Ready Player One’s Oasis, Sword Art Online’s NerveGear, Ghost in the Shell’s deep dives… that sort of “total immersion” technology is often considered the absolute silver bullet of gaming. But even below that level of total immersion, there seems to be a belief that adding finer details and more realism makes for better games.

The underlying idea is pretty straight forward: immersion is good and thus more immersion is “more better”. The more immersive and the more realistic things get, the more enjoyable the game will be. I don’t think that’s true though.

If you define flow as the thing you want, then you’ll easily see, that more immersiveness and more realism does not equal more flow. You just need immersion to be good enough - and the game to be free of things that break immersion - so that flow can be achieved and maintained. And that does often require more abstraction, more simplification and more skipping and ignoring details that would just be boring, tedious or anxiety inducing. You often have to simplify the rules to be learnable, provide clear goals and unambiguous feedback, and boil things down to just the friction that you want the game’s challenge to be about.

More immersiveness does provide a more realistic and more detailed and more complete experience - but when it comes to games and gameplay, that might actually be counter-productive to what makes a game fun and enjoyable. I’d rather lazily hang on a couch while feeling like a parkour god in Assassin’s Creed or Mirror’s Edge, than actually exerting myself in a VR treadmill, getting all sweaty and out of breath. That might be great for a game that’s about that and actually places its challenge and mastery in overcoming exactly that friction of real-life physical exertion. But most games do not.

To me, the best and most interesting games are those, which put their challenge into player decisions. Decisions you have to make, which then have consequences you have to deal with. And these meaningful decisions can take many different forms, like where to spend skill points in Grim Dawn, which dialogue answers to pick in Mass Effect, what moral dilemma choices to make in FrostPunk, whether to have to peace or war with a neighbour in Civilization, which missions to pick in XCOM, how to build my fortress in Dwarf Fortress.

And for that kind of challenge to induce flow - I don’t need bathroom mechanics, or a Holodeck, or a VR treadmill, or even 3D graphics. ASCII art might be perfectly good enough in some cases. Sure, that’s overall less immersive - but I’m fully willing to suspend disbelief and thus it only has to be immersive enough that I can find flow.

This isn’t supposed to be a slight on VR or on immersive experiences. Those are great in their own right, and totally interesting and worthwhile. But when it comes to games and what makes for good gameplay, all of that stuff might be tangential at best.

When the experience you want is that of a walking simulator (and I’m not using that term derogatorily here) - having a VR treadmill might actually elevate that. Second Life and VRChat might also benefit from increased immersiveness - those are more “immersive places” and less “games” to begin with. But something like chess doesn’t become a better game, when it’s played in photorealistic VR, overseeing a real battlefield full of medieval combatants, vs. being played purely in ASCII graphics. Chess is a good game, purely because of its rules and abstractions. All that’s needed from the board and figures is to provide clarity and readability of the current game state. The visual depiction is purely meant to help with clarity and being unambiguous and understandable.

Sometimes, - I’d even dare go as far as saying “often” - increased immersiveness and increased simulation detail might actually add bad friction and thus detract from flow - rather than add to it.

This post is licensed under CC BY 4.0 by the author.